While
gathering research for my upcoming podcast, I had to make a choice between
using library databases and Google Scholar. I searched on Google Scholar for
information about my research question: Will 3D printing facilitate the
decentralisation of the means of production? I entered a simple Boolean search
phrase which looked something like this:
Stereolithography
OR 3D printing OR Fused Deposition Modeling AND decentralisation
(Stereolithography
and Fused deposition modeling were alternative search terms for 3D printing) I
ended up with a lot of results and I didn’t know how to refine my search
further, so Google Scholar ended up not being useful to me. The words of “Fused
Deposition Modeling” ended up not being together and I didn’t know how to
mitigate that. York databases gave me a lot more articles than google scholar,
so I ended up picking a source from one of the databases and none from Scholar.
The source is 3D printing: Convergence, Friction, Fluidity by Robert Ree.
The other
source I got much of my information from was The Maker’s Revolution, found
here:
http://longnow.org/seminars/02013/feb/19/makers-revolution/
I found
the Maker’s Revolution extra helpful, so I ended up citing Chris Anderson over
and over in my podcast transcript. My last useful source was a library book. Rapid Manufacturing: An Industrial
Revolution for the Digital Age. I used it mostly for technical information
about the processes of stereolithography and fused deposition modeling (FDM). I
didn’t want to get into too many sources because I knew I would have to
interact with them during the podcast, and it would be hard for the listener to
keep track of many sources. These sources proved sufficient for 1800 words. (I
will need to see if that’s 15 minutes)
One
worry that I have is that I ended up regurgitating the information that I found
in my sources, especially Chris Anderson. I tried to mitigate that by adding my
original observations in a couple areas in the piece.
How might Google Scholar and York databases be useful in combination?
I
honestly don’t know, because Scholar ended up not being useful to me. Scholar
is a databases, and York databases are well, databases, so I don’t see what
makes Scholar different from other databases.
Will I rely on Google Scholar or York databases in the
future?
Scholar
is really easily accessible, so in future projects I will see what it has to
offer, but I will probably rely on York database. Of course, I won’t be able to
use York databases if I stop being a student at York, so my options may be
limited.
In lecture I tried to demonstrate how to find alternative search terms - synonyms - to use if you're not finding much. You could have used "makers revolution" or Anderson's name then looked for other papers and books he's published and used the "cited by" and "related" options in google scholar to expand your search from there.
ReplyDelete