Sunday, 2 March 2014

U of Goog vs The Almighty Library

So it feels like it has been forever since I had to write a blog post for this class. Feels good to be back, a couple of grades under my belt and the end of the semester drawing ever closer. So now that I've finally got a first draft for my podcast in as well as my revised research plan, let's do a little reflecting shall we?

Alright so I want to talk about Google Scholar and Library Databases, specifically York's Online Library database. I found myself using both for this project and had varying results with both. Let's start with Google Scholar.

Google Scholar is really simple and really easy to navigate which is nice and convenient and they let me sort my search results by various factors like how recent they were or how many other sources cited this work. This made finding sources very easy. However the problem as it often is with google is that they give you a vast ocean of information of which only a small bit is useful. I would find some good links but a lot of what I got was unpublished journals and papers by grad students or for professors who's credibility was questionable at best. The other thing I encountered a lot was GREAT sources hidden behind pay walls which forced me to go to the york u library database to see if the school had a license with the database behind which this source was hidden. So in the future I think Google Scholar is a nice place to get my researching feet wet but it can be really dodgy and unreliable sometimes.

Now on the other hand we Library Databases. These things can bring magnificent results when you use them right. They certainly helped me find a lot of great scholarly and popular sources. Of which I only used a fraction that were truly relevant but many of them helped me really wrap my head around where I was taking this podcast. However there is a major draw back to these. Most of these cost money. Thankfully York has a pass to most of them so that's not a real issue now but in the future that's something I'll need to consider. Beyond that though, these damn things are Labyrinths. I would see a source that seems like it might be helpful click a "Read this text" link and be taken to another site that has an abstract and another link to another database with the link to the full text. This sort of hoop jumping frustrates the hell out of me and made the research process even longer.

So basically what I'm trying to get at here is that Google Scholar is eaiser, more user friendly and free, however the sources are often unreliable so you need to dig through a lot of stuff. Library Databases are powerful and chock full of great sources but are complex to navigate, rely on you to be very specific with search terms, cost money and make you jump through hoops to get to one source. So in the future so long as I am still a york student I will use both in tandem because the are good counterpoints to one another. But when the day comes that I need to pay to use proquest unless I have a job that necessitates it I can't say I'll continue to use databases.

BC signing off!
Tune Of The Week!

1 comment:

  1. Insightful analysis. I tend to agree. I use both in tandem to this day - Google Scholar to become familiar with a topic and refine my list of search terms and then the library databases once I'm more familiar with the nature of the conversation I'm looking to tap into.

    ReplyDelete