Monday, 3 March 2014

Google Scholar Versus York University Library Databases

The research strategies that we reviewed in class were very helpful to me. Prior to our classes I knew about Google Scholar but I never actively sought it out as a source to use. I would always normally use the Library Databases. Now I have two databases I can use when I'm facing the very different environments of researching. I still use Library Databases as my number one reference tool because I trust it more. Partly, I suppose that has to do my background with the database and that I am used to using it. I also prefer the Library Databases more because, in retrospect, I have found many more reliable articles through the Databases than I have in Google Scholar. In searching some the authors I have found while using Google Scholar, there has been very little to no information surrounding some of them. It takes a longer time to dig though the information until I can find something that is worthwhile. 

There are, of courses differences between Google Scholar and the Library Databases. Some of the key differences start out with specificity. The point I want to try and make here has nothing to do with refining searches. Both search engines expertly allow for excellent refinement of topics.  What I do mean is that through the Library Databases you can access other specific search engines that cater to the specific topic material you are searching for. In Google Scholar does not have this extra assistance (or at least not that I have found). Another difference is that Google Scholar provides a preview of the articles, journals, etc without having to click on the title to get a notion of the usability of the source. This saves a lot of time, especially if someone is doing a general search. Google Scholar though, allows users to save the references they have found on their database and they also proved a "related articles" option. 

For ease of use, Google Scholar would be the option to use. But in the future I will still continue to rely on the Library Databases. Although they might not be as accessible or straight forward, I feel that the sources I find there will generally be more useful than searches using Google Scholar. I will not neglect Google though, for it opens avenues that the Library Databases may not.

Marina Green

No comments:

Post a Comment