Here is my final script. Keep in mind I do not say everything here word for word. Unfortunately, the quality is not the best. I suspect I am not enunciating quite good enough.
3D Printing: The
Manufacturing Revolution
Approximate
length: 16 minutes, 40 seconds
Play 10-15 seconds of “There’s a Good
Possibility”. (freeplaymusic.com)
Fade out music, fade in my voice.
Alex:
There’s a new industrial revolution on the horizon, according to Chris Anderson
in The Makers Revolution. The Maker’s
Revolution is a seminar for The Long Now, available at longnow.org/seminars.
This new industrial revolution has the potential to be like the first
industrial revolution, the one that occurred in Europe in the 1800’s. But there
were other industrial revolutions, too. One that Anderson is concerned about is
the introduction of the internet. The internet was a revolution in communication
that let anyone communicate with anyone. So what’s the big technology that
Anderson is so excited about? Well, it’s getting there. But it’s also been
around a long time, even longer than the internet. So, what is it? You may have
heard of it as 3D printing.
Hello. I’m your host, Alex Legard. I
hope you enjoy the podcast.
Break.
Alex:
The industrial revolution of the 1800s moved people toward the machinery of
capitalism in large numbers. Even though Anderson explained it was a little
dark, it actually improved life expectancy by a big margin. Before that, going
as far back as ancient Greek and Roman times, life expectancy was static.
According to Sharon Basaraba, a contributor to about.com, people in ancient
Greece or Rome lived to around 20-35, and life expectancy in Europe was 30-40
as late as 1800.
So on to the second industrial
revolution: The introduction of the internet and the communications revolution
that followed. The internet was a huge, open medium for people to express
themselves. The revolutionary thing about it was that everybody was equal. It
was not discriminate toward professionals. You didn’t have to be a novelist, or
a newspaper writer, in order for other people to read what you had to say. This
was a bad thing in some ways, for example who likes to read somebody who
doesn’t know what they’re talking about? But certainly, the internet was a good
thing in other ways, too.
Chris Anderson said, putting power
in the hands of the people is a big deal. The industrial revolution empowered
people by raising life expectancy. The internet revolution empowered people by
giving people the power of communication to a global audience. 3D printing has
the potential to allow people to print off a range of things, like dolls,
figurines, transformer toys, you name it. The ability of people to make the
stuff they want is the power of manufacturing. I will go into the many aspects
of this new “manufacturing revolution”.
Break.
Alex:
3D printing consists of a whole range of technologies, ranging from the
commercial to the personal. The number of technologies in 3D printing is quite
numerous, but I’m going to talk about two that are very common. One is a
liquid-to-solid technology called stereolithography. Another is called Fused
Deposition Modeling, often abbreviated as FDM.
Stereolithography is the oldest 3D printing technology in the
book, patented by Charles Hull in 1986. That’s according to Hopkins, Hague, and
Dickens in Rapid Manufacturing: An
Industrial Revolution for the Digital Age. Stereolithography was used as a
prototyping technology, not to actually make finished products, but it was the
first of its kind. Instead of making a widget and inspecting it, which could
take a long time, the employee simply prints off a design created on a CAD file
- That stands for computer-aided design - and once the printing is complete,
they can hold it in their own hands. Stereolithography was just a time and
money saving procedure. The technology uses a device that used a laser and a
liquid resin to build an object one layer at a time. The laser is moved by a
computer that performs the printing process. The liquid is a photocurable
resin. That means that the liquid can only be hardened by the computer-guided
laser. Once the process is complete, you’ll appear to have a big pool of liquid.
That’s the point when you simply pull your design out.
That’s stereolithography. Fused
Deposition modeling is a technology that was patented to Scott Crump, the
founder of Stratasys in 1991, according to the book Rapid Manufacturing. Before I explain how it works, it will help to
explain the similarities and differences between Fused deposition modeling and
a simple, non-3D printer. A printer has a nozzle that travels across a blank
sheet of paper. The nozzle travels in layers, until eventually, the whole sheet
of paper is covered in ink. Fused deposition modeling technologies, or FDM,
take a solid material, in a non-powder form, and superheats it so it can be applied
to our object. The Makerbot line of 3D printers uses FDM, according to the
Forbes article, “Why did Stratysys pay so Much for Makerbot?” (sic) According
to the Makerbot website, the material that their 3D printers use is the
Makerbot PLA filament: “A bioplastic derived from corn”.
According to the Stratasys website,
An FDM-based printer prints off objects one layer at a time. Pretend that it
places every bottom piece of a castle, made of Legos. Then the printer adds a
second layer by adding all the Lego pieces that go on top of the first layer.
Then it adds the third layer, which goes on top of the second layer, and so on.
The printer goes on and on and on and on and on, until finally, almost every
layer is complete. When it finally places the top layer, you’re finally done.
Now, because of the way that 3D
printers create things, they can do a lot of neat things. For one, you can make
things inside other things. So for example, you can make a chain where the
links can’t be separated. Or you can Make a ball inside of a bigger ball. Or a
ball inside a ball inside a ball. Or you can create tools with adjustable
parts.
Moving on, the materials you can use
depend on the 3D printer you’re using. The Makerbot line of 3D printers uses
the Makerbot PLA filament: According to the Makerbot website, it’s a bioplastic
made of corn. The mini metal maker is a prototype 3D printer that does metal.
The website for that is minimetalmaker.com. Unfortunately, you can’t print with
multiple materials using a desktop 3D printer, according to Anderson.
Anderson explains, the computer that
does the printing uses a CAD file to know what it has to do. That stands for
Computer-Aided Design. Every CAD file is created by somebody. When using a CAD
program, there is a large, virtual space that lets you build 3-dimensional
objects. Any shape you can think of, you can make. Many designers go to school
to learn to use CAD.
Break.
Alex:
That’s basically what 3D printing is. My original objective of this podcast was
to explore the aspects of 3D printing as the cause of a “manufacturing
revolution”. So let me get right to that.
One special thing about 3D printing
is CAD. CAD is being taught in high schools, like the high school I went to. I
took a technological design course in grade eleven I believe, and a big part of
the course was using CAD to plan a couple of woodworking projects. I remember
that it wasn’t particularly hard, and the hardest part was finding out how to
make particular kinds of curves, and whatnot.
Furthermore, Kids are doing the same
thing that professionals do who use CAD. They’re building things with Legos.
They’re playing Minecraft. Minecraft is a game that puts you in a huge
wilderness of cubes of different materials, like block trees and block dirt and
block rocks, and it lets you build anything you want, as long as you got the
materials and the imagination. Kids play Minecraft because it’s fun and they
get to use their imagination. For the record, I used to play with K’NEX, another
construction toy. If you put kids next to CAD, they’ll be able to pick it up
more easily, because it’s a lot like the stuff they do for fun on their free
time.
Finally printing it is easy. People
can make whatever they want, print it off, and hold it in their hands. This is great.
Not only can people save money, they can get customisable stuff more easily
than ever before. According to Robert Ree, who wrote his dissertation 3D Printing: Convergences, Friction,
Fluidity, people are empowered in ways like the expression of their own
personal tastes, or use of custom tools to accomplish tasks.
Companies are also using 3D printing
to allow customisation of products, so people can express their personal tastes
especially easily. This is according to Robert Ree in his dissertation. For
example, websites such as iTunes and Amazon collect data on individuals and
create recommendations based on their personal history. With 3D printing, the
conception of customisation would be taken one step further, because it would
be used to make finished products for consumers. Nike, on their website, is
selling customisable shoes. Consumers can alter size and colors of the shoes
and choose to add initials to the exterior. According to Ree, the people would
become participants in the design of the product, not just recipients.
So, 3D printers seem amazing, right?
But even though they’re already around, they’re not cheap. Therefore, they’re
not in usage. Often technology undergoes transformations when it becomes
cheaper. Developers create innovations to meet the needs of a massive audience.
The technology makes the move from the commercial to the personal. Case in
point is the introduction of the personal computer. The personal computer
reached an affordable price range in the early 1990’s. You could imagine what
that meant for IBM, or International Business Machines: a company that
specialised in making computers for business. In 1993, IBM lost $8.1 billion,
according to their own website. The computer revolution contributed to that
staggering loss.
Unfortunately, 3D printers aren’t
there yet. For example, the Makerbot 3D printers are still in the 4 digit price
range. The Makerbot Replicator Mini Compact Printer is $1,375, the Makerbot
Replicator Desktop Printer is $2,899, and the Makerbot Replicator Z18 Printer
is $6,499. That’s definitely too expensive for most consumers, but they’re
getting cheaper.
A significant point, which relates
back to the “manufacturing revolution”, is that factories in China are moving
away from big-batch manufacturing and moving towards individual manufacturing,
according to Anderson. Previously you would have to wait months and have to
travel to Hong Kong to meet with factory owners and have dinner with them, then
they would make 50 000 of the same design. Now, you don’t have to do that
anymore because they realised the internet is a more lucrative market. Chris
Anderson said, “I got robots in China to work for me, and they took Paypal ...
And if I can do it anybody can do it”.
So 3D printing facilitates both
customisation of products and decentralisation of the means of production. In
this world, people could print off things they want themselves. companies would
also play a role in creating printable products. But unlike before, these
companies would need to take a step back and see consumers with specific tastes.
Another ramification of 3D printing
would be in the area of copyright and intellectual property. Both Ree and
Anderson identify this as a problem. Because, as Anderson explains,
intellectual property applies to ideas, not things. If I were to print off a
figurine of, say, Super Mario and give it to someone, can anyone really bring
me to court? Would there be a difference if I were to sell it?
According to the government of
Canada, no, you can’t be prosecuted. As it says in A Guide to Copyright from the Canadian Intellectual property
office, copyright applies to literary works, dramatic works, musical works, and
artistic works. So Anderson is right. No mention is made about things. This is
a gap that will need to be addressed by lawmakers if 3D printing becomes
mainstream.
Also recently, a couple of 3D
printers were acquired by Toronto Library. 3D printers are still coming down in
price, which means that more libraries will be able to afford it in the future.
If the local library could afford a computer lab, it’s within reason that they
can acquire a few 3D printers. If people could use a 3D printer at the local
library, what would they do? Probably use it if they had an idea of something
they wanted to make. They’d probably use it if they could save a reasonable amount
of money on something. According to the Star’s article, “Toronto Public Library
Goes Digital With 3D Printing, Technology Hubs”, there would also be a focus on
teaching computer programming - presumably using a CAD program. This would draw
more people in to be able to use 3D printers.
Break.
Now everything I’ve said, how does it
make up a manufacturing revolution? One aspect was that people - especially
kids - have the ability to use CAD, which would allow them to make 3D printable
designs. If they become available in libraries, they would become accessible to
an even greater number of people. 3D printing also allows individuals to express
their personal tastes that simply are not possible in the traditional
manufacturing system. I discussed the move of the Chinese manufacturing
industry to small-scale manufacturing. 3D printers should also give a heads-up
to lawmakers because of the ramifications to copyright law.
Break.
Alex:
Do you have your own observations? Leave them as a reply to this comment below.
I’m Alex Legard, and I hope you learned some things about 3D printing. Thanks
for listening.
No comments:
Post a Comment