Tuesday, 4 March 2014

Google Scholar vs. Library Database

How did I research race and crime in America?  Well, I'll tell you I didn't use Google Scholar.  My decision was based on experience.  I've tried researching literary topics on Google Scholar.  For the most part, I ended up finding a web link to a database that is accessible through York University's "Passport York."  Instead of Google Scholar, I use library databases,specifically, York University Library's database, why not?--we already pay for it.

Researching race and crime in America through York University's Library database is an accessible and effective experience.  After a keyword search of "race crime America," I found books (yes, books) that analyzed the aggregation of crime in low-income neighbourhoods, which are home to a large population of visible minorities in America.  The books didn't just contain a single article or essay on race and crime in America; I found multiple and various articles within these books, and the best part was that each article addressed specific theories and perspectives on the topic that I couldn't have imagined. A Google Scholar search of race and crime in America resulted in multiple sources that also analyzed the issue of race, ethnicity and crime in American low-income areas.  There wasn't a particular problem with these sources, except these are books that I would have to buy.  Although I didn't have to pay for the books I cited from York's Library database, traversing the maze that is Scott Library is a challenge in itself, but the virtuous strive on.

In comparison to Google Scholar, library databases, in particular, York University's Library database is a more efficient, trustworthy, and cost-benefit research tool.


Peace out,
David.

No comments:

Post a Comment